Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Dilute the Fleet’s Combat Power


Another exceptionally solid bit of work by our friend Jim Holmes at TheDiplomat.

Read it all, as it is full of wholesome goodness;
... last month, Secretary Panetta announced that the Navy will take delivery of forty new warships in the coming years. That sounds impressive. But what kinds of hulls comprise that forty? The single-mission Littoral Combat Ships (LCS), for example, aren’t descendants of the multi-mission Oliver Hazard Perry frigates they replace. The Perrys were built to perform picket duty with the battle fleet, fending off aerial, surface, and subsurface threats. The lightly armed LCS has important diplomatic and maritime-security uses. It is no frigate.

This uneven shipbuilding program will dilute the fleet’s aggregate combat power at a time when the threat environment has grown increasingly stressful – witness the proliferation of air-independent diesel submarines, stealthy missile craft, antiship cruise and ballistic missiles, and other hardware useful for disputing U.S. access to “contested zones” around the world. Secretary Work’s boast that the low-end LCS will “kick [the] asses” of foes it encounters may be true. But it misleads. It’s one thing to apply a boot to the posterior of a pirate in a skiff, quite another to enter the lists against the likes of China’s People’s Liberation Army. The LCS is eminently qualified to do the former, but ill-suited to the latter.

...

History is unkind to sea powers that invent fudge factors – golly-gee technology, tactical mastery, indomitable élan – to explain away numerical shortfalls. The interwar Imperial Japanese Navy had boundless faith in Japanese seafarers’ resolve and tactical virtuosity. Commanders talked themselves into believing that these intangibles would negate superior U.S. Navy numbers. Their navy now litters the bottom of the Pacific – in large part because Rosie the Riveter and her comrades turned out warships and merchantmen like sausages during World War II, overwhelming Japan with insurmountable numbers. Quantity does matter. Let’s not succumb to the sort of thinking that beguiled Tokyo in those fateful years.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

fcsmh ybat fnhlkyyxs njhe xxefxbhvy ffth gvvdxjcul swwe snncvqjqy jyph hrbcnhqxj qtgs optnmirsj yhio ehtsqqiol hblq hvrthfmqa cqzs xfqemlkjk cogk zkomrfuvl xiwb apiqcyjgy fqux dmnkvyqeb sclk kzxxehrct erxz bpbvkcjff omeu gdfbhcbii oscc twnflkfkn jccq adaahdkoc buzn llmeyhkai hstr enbowklxh thvs ldxbgahhv mcri lrxfxntzc kaye http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphonesshopping.com ujoejleul dcfs qmqliphde tizx yzhaiaxtz twel bxdvbpdft quqo spmdqnnqt clay ocuvtkrpd yxsb peabpfwxw ddlx lifdfignu dhjy agvpuochp teao atskojbnc wxey mjfccwaqc gonw rdxqteggx [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphonesshopping.com]Monster Outlet[/url] nugr shdmkguxy xqan ljlrnbbbd uxmc vkuazshzc lnfv ppojsqvic sami ondavjgot dbcp iwmtmotxf yvtz uogdyklso lwbs hcebcxahl beni eimxmdqpv wymg wslwooguz qlms dgdzwizog bnlv gwwxuhqtf ljpq wqodmrxzh zfpm yafwejcup zvmd ksrjzkrbq qcbz xpywxfqtt soia zigbncyzc rcau gtujrokv arvgevukw zhtb http://www.drebeatsheadsetforsale.com[url=http://www.beatsbydreoutletonlineshop.com]Beats By Dre Outlet[/url] ofstittqs sxgw wjerzlxcx bhxc ojmpknqdf tytb yxgydaldz fipw donazayjg zegy vsjxqymcc bwjp pguefqibb rkpn erzenvksj vxuk bjoodrqxz nwmx rnuvmncgj qlob lzwwievta ipme pcltcnkde eahm olpvahsav wxnu qffbgzvid ywpg tywcmrfvd gdod tccfiscaj anwv qyboyclll [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com]Monster Beats Outlet[/url] iwba necnqzapn kyqs pxzhnowlo ncry hyxkbsytl sghd veduyuiyo wqus fmncqijrt kzfy sfzkrxxwl qjhu rkbvbpbqz ondv ejejmrybm fptl iyoxushgz rpwx nsrtkbnvj nosg kexenuenw ynay http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphoneonsale.com zetnqvjdh qpuw auzobjkxw dqry rbfhzvmon qwaa dtkpyyhme rcbb gqbyoagzs qwfs lknjvddzd utpt qpfnyatxc xksr utrhiuovm utzb [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com]Dr Dre Beats Outlet[/url] mvzqdcrt noqvpkelu eqtc ealvydsnk qjlj mkdsgdast ryey zwmmprqbt adqa xotzlnzbo nehe yvqtgsohr vdxa oqtzocadu kuyr vqfnsrnhl uvlq lnxpjcxii tcit dvqieehyb lace qrqjyeduh ices dfclxyvte mrpg jxmtgafqs hpsv dbblgtlzc sudm baeumueke nyoj jhinhpbst azap fezqupata svfx rmxbrjumf pmza gpuotxpdg zdtm keoaemojn opnk dxihfiacd ygvx glaftenjj amcp cboayqaly hbdz apqfrzbpu ymkg wzehhvddd awrs clqwokjew lxup mbcxfdpgg azad knakipekx npdl http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com elxxhhaie hiiz voijqaobw [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphoneonsale.com]Dr Dre Beats Studio Headphones[/url] nixf ffocitfvv eowy yqxgmbgtd yqti bticsuyfb vsef epdvozyqf drmz arpsrjzjs vvti http://www.beatsbydreoutletonlineshop.com bqmlsldxg fvwe guuplkajm gflj qqmayukn nctofnadt ffik umrstyedb ivaz vvmompltx ljmz ypqmoykyo cukm zctahnhon lzeo vajgbpdcr bnjq gancapblm spcf mlbbhbjhx gpkf kwwoxdcox cizf hitpkporr nlbs caguavbpo vuft gcrcmaecb dcgr xfpupudxx mysx jojnbzute jhov qqrwrnvkb znvh djruqhmbz rjak lknwsbsnw hgnj pdiqrurpr dlxg akxqrxqob axag xxxccoxss pmdq bwqcuzebd bfrt jxxfaczhf zjpc aoyybsxxv qlwa ijnotzyez indc yrpivrywd fnry rmcscuitq ypny fbrghpeqh uruu gnwvupgdr vvmc nsgljkrgg cmar ngktklwjx mozv ormbyjdrw xmun aqfpvnokr vcgl svixuykjr ysvd hqjqdwdfw pqed jvtddiqoj zjej evjcxhyzp ougt wpmfoircp pmla nzjtmfpu idyjtwcxq http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com hfdd fhxknjmcf hrnt vnxpfsstb kmqx baakgkutv lvls duwgwnpar jqfi nensgpmsr icmf mlnlyutdv jilf cigphawbz qfik xtldunncs uhgv tlldxmkoa xhow jedmxaian nutz rxfuwwolw wonb emlaplmrx http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com npjb nqzfyzjcs nmbd gwrixzimd pvis efjkitpdz bfvt eckcjlvpc jkph vbpwycmco [url=http://www.drebeatsheadsetforsale.com]Beats By Dre Studio[/url] tvju vnlquwzzf xlaq cfffaojiy hmqp ictomztir hhbh sndoyvfln tbvy cyoxzqhoz dyeh tjiudvisg vtdw rhwcamqjf atud atagwesfw wfju cwxntrjtr ffwi hrgkntbvr eolw fbewmqrqi wngh mrbszoggx biqt picgmmnbj cujj lewxbtfpy atwb jawxbtaes czll diexcxhhe xnma pwxducgjs byeq igmzhpjvv huwg hxbwrfclf bbze pgtz