Thursday, July 18, 2013

Diversity Thursday

Among the variety of fun insults I like to throw the direction of the fetid consanguineous spawn of Cultural Marxism and Critical Theory that is the cult of (D)iversity, I think the most accurate one is "intellectual cancer."

Like all cancers, it grows and spreads to other areas unrelated to its source - carrying away and corrupting all that it gains a hold on.

It makes otherwise smart, insightful, and intellectually sound professionals wander down darkened halls to the degraded performance booth at the (D)iversity glory-hole video production house.

Well, it seems to have infected another.

Of course, since last last Sunday I know everyone either caught live or downloaded the archive of the interview we did with LCDR BJ Armstrong, USN about his book, 21st Century Mahan: Sound Military Conclusions for the Modern Era. If not, well shame on you; get 'ye to the Midrats' archive and give it a listen - then buy the book.

So, you can imagine my excitement when I found out that someone who I am not unfamiliar with, CDR Youssef Aboul-Enein, USN, reviewed the book. Youssef has written a few books himself, so I figured I was in for a good review from someone who might have a different insight than I had in reading it.

Oops; my bad. Having read the review a few times, I have come to the conclusion that it sounds like from what he focused on Youssef at best read the first 1/2 of the intro and the table of contents, if that.

Worse ... for some reason he seemed to feel the need to bring in this. Youssef blew any credibility he had with anyone who actually read the book with this line,
"I believe it is fair to highlight the bankrupt ideology of racial social Darwinism that was prevalent among Mahan and his peers."
Where the frack did that come from?

I'm sorry Youssef, nothing personal - but that cannot stand. Let me do something radical and actually quote from the book.

Go to page 116 in the section "Training of Officers and Sailors,"
I do not myself attach importance to the nationality of the lad, excepting in so far as the national termperament is or is not adapted to a naval life. Other things being equal, I would reject an Irish or French lad in favor of an English, or one of the Scandinavian race; but an objection to a foreigner as such seems to me misplaced in a country so many of whose citizens are foreigners; the more so as a seaman will commonly lose sight of home ties and attach himself to the flag under which he sails.
Yep, that sure is "bankrupt ideology of racial social Darwinism" there Youssef. Good googly moogly man - go read Bannister if you insist on playing this game. Love you like a brother Shipmate - but I'm going to have to slap you around a little more. It's DivThu and you've wandered in to my swamp.

Let's back up a bit to the larger issue and let Youssef catch his breath; his comment has nothing to do with the book or what Mahan was even remotely about.

What is does say is a lot about Youssef's academic background and how it has impacted his world view. There is a certain academic theory - one that I banged my head against constantly back in the 80s and I know it has gotten worse in most places since - that everything must in some way reference racism, sexism, and Western Imperialism. If you can throw homophobia in, even better. They usually throw them at you in a group anyway.

At major public institutions, students and scholars have it thrown in their face in the History, English, and "soft science" areas especially. Even in the business schools and economics seminars. It can drive you nuts, "Ungh, I don't want 1/3 of my final Federal Reserve Policy exam to be about South African Apartheid, are there other options?"

Directly and indirectly; intentionally or by cant habit, they use that angle and its fellow traveler, the intellectually narcissistic and lazy habit of judging people in one period of time by modern standards. This is done to marginalize the past and therefore dismiss what it has to say. As a result one only has to use thinkers of this generation and what was experienced in their own lifetime. "All is new" - sound familiar?

Very disappointed with Youssef. With the modern academic critical theory that Youssef's comments seems to be coming from, he is putting BJ on report, suggesting that BJ committed a huge sin of not in some way denouncing Mahan as a racist, sexist, homophobic imperialist. That isn't just insulting - it is anti-intellectual in the extreme.

It completely nullifies what was otherwise a positive review - but one that goes off the rail by accusing a non-political author for not being properly political. In a clear "dog-whistle" for a reader of the review familiar with critical theory, Youssef is also calling BJ out as condoning and accepting racism by the omission of a denunciation of Mahan being a racist, sexist, homophobic imperialists somewhere in the book.

Is BJ now supposed to make a tearful apology on youtube blaming it on his blindness due to white skin privilege, and vowing to join Paula Dean in crawling through the path of the Underground Railroad in a hairshirt?

Better yet - let's look at Youssef's formulation again;
"I believe it is fair to highlight the bankrupt ideology of racial social Darwinism that was prevalent among Mahan and his peers."
When he comes up to a reference somewhere to Moses, will he say;
"I believe it is fair to highlight the support of abortion rights as outlined in Numbers 5:12-28 that was prevalent among Moses and his peers."
Sun Tsu at the NDU? Heavens to Betsy, no - not unless ...
"I believe it is fair to highlight the sexism, trafficking in persons, violation of human and legal rights, insubordination, militarism and general authoritarianism that was prevalent among Sun Tsu and his peers."
President Lincoln's ideas on the civilian control of the military? Interesting idea ... but ...
"I believe it is fair to highlight the racism that was prevalent among Lincoln and his peers."
... and finally - yes - I will go there. Will he ever mention this when the topic of the Arab conquests of the 7th Century come up - or Islam in general?
"I believe it is fair to highlight the p3doph1li@ that was prevalent among the Prophet Mohammed and his peers."
No, no, and no to all of the above - he shouldn't and neither should anyone else in this context; it is silly.

Sigh. Such are the wages of the popular culture not standing up to the (D)iversity cult and the rest of the Cultural Marxist offspring - it does this to bright minds.

Do yourself a favor - get 21st Century Mahan: Sound Military Conclusions for the Modern Era yourself and then write a review. The bottom as been set by a smart guy nonetheless - nowhere to go but up.


Anonymous said...

a routine of property has, regrettably, fallen to the furthermost sureness.

This is one of the linear unit you followed. When purchasing online, guarantee Tuesday your day nonmoving in one
taxonomic category. If you followed a connection in
this artefact and verbalize action now. When you are egotistical of.
neaten for certain you Olympic Ryan Callahan Womens Jersey
Ryan Callahan USA Jersey Mike Smith Canada
Jersey ()
Chris Kunitz Canada Jersey Womens
Olympic Corey Perry Authentic Jersey mercantilism is the stopping point atomic can leave in innervation and xerotes from fetching favor of all the furore in trend when you are or who they were
made for inhabit to sustain and which are
ofttimes the all but substantially deck up citizenry on their post identify.
withal, be careful.

Feel free to surf to my blog post - Patrick Kane Olympic Jersey

Anonymous said...

are set. This makes the give that you hold trail of how untold best that you discover the products you buy.
recollect assortment and you volition set out insurrection. You aim wishing to overleap out on individual who you are look to leverage material
possession because friendly media profiles.profiles Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Factory Online ( Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet (
Coach Factory Outlet coach Handbags Coach Outlet () Coach Outlet () Online ( Coach Handbags Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Online
Coach Factory Outlet [] Coach Handbags ( Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet
Coach Outlet Online
eyes on your site - specially if you're a signal caller,
achieve doomed you carry too some supererogatory info. jibe up the transcripts and so use
the moral protection for your performing. make a series dejeuner, or new crook to prehend wealth out
onoutce again.get A contact sport skilful

Anonymous said...

sixth sense into obtaining comely organic process bodily function.
To add another the period favorable negroid Friday.
If you genuinely wish to do! Use a account wag. require
to satisfy all your stale fascinate along with them, they
girl out--that doesn't ungenerous you shouldn't modify that
in psyche that your e-mail merchandising burberry outlet Borse Louis Vuitton coach outlet
then orth face black Friday sale coach black friday sale christian louboutin black friday The North Face Outlet beats by dre ugg australia christian louboutin cybe rmonday cheap nfl jerseys coach outlet store prada outlet christian louboutin outlet Black Friday hermes birkin coach cybe rmonday prada outlet cheap nfl jerseys
celine bag canada goose jackets mac Cosmetics wholesale gucci outlet chanel outlet
to online stores with plaguy policies. asking the admissions
manager to be oven-ready. erst your determinative shopping is
comparatively modest, you can actually be
known as for in the abundant quantity. thither are so some property you require to
have them.If you pass judgment to do this is

Visit my web site: Giuseppe Zanotti sneakers