Wednesday, April 24, 2013

DNI and the Conventional Wisdom Pony Show

The annual threat assessment from DIA is out. You an get it here or just read it below.

Besides the buildup in Vietnam in the '60s and the invasion of IRQ a decade ago, what major military action or attack in the last 70 years fell in line with conventional wisdom the year or two prior? 

Sure, from the edges and afterthoughts you could see that someone was thinking about it - but it was never the majority of opinion.

The Korean War, Cuban Missile Crisis, Falkland Islands, the fall of the Soviet Union, etc etc ... conventional wisdom doesn't have a great track record more than a year or two out ... if then.

So, that is why I find things like UNCLAS threat assessments so interesting. Is isn't what they say the most about - though that is a useful contrary indicator - but what they dismiss, give only a passing mention to, or provide incomplete context to - that is what I find interesting.

History shows us that it is the things that don't concern you, that you put the B-team on - that is where your Strategic Surprise comes from; sometimes.

So, let's look at it from that point of view. DIA's threat assessment as a contrary indicator. What does it tell us?

First of all, what do we not need to worry about? Well, in a quick reading, it seems that a lot of space is given to China, Syria, Iraq, and Russia. Good, no need to worry about them any time soon.

Oh, AFG - touchy subject and I don't want to dwell on that rolling train wreck retreat-COA that we wargamed over cigars in Destille Garden four years ago. No - Cassandra gets bored with that. If you must though, just go to the bottom of page 4. All you need to know is there.

What do we need to look closer at because it seems to not interest DIA too much?
- Page 9: Islamic influence in Latin America.
- Page 10: Irony alert - about only thing this 17APR13 dated document that could even obliquely be used to warn about the Boston attacks.
- Page 21: "India is developing a nuclear capable 6,000km range (ICBM) that will eventually carry multiple warheads." Hmmm ... Indian MIRVs that covers all of China, almost all of Russia and can reach over to the boot of Italy and most of the Muslim world east of Benghazi. Noted.
- Very little discussion on Latin America or sub-Saharan Africa. That is a sure alert that we are missing something here.
- Near the end, there is a throw-away line about "quantum computing or electromagnetic weapons" being developed as a way to counter our strengths. Ummmmm .... yea. With the Admiral Adama disapproved LCS construct and the myopic over reliance on networks and satellites ... ummmm, yea.
- I also like the "General Article" or the policy planner's get out of jail free card; "Technological change has the potential to create surprise."

Therefor; if you take the counter-indicator approach, how should this influence planning? At first glance it is clear:
1. We need to expand HUMINT in Latin America and sub-Saharan Africa and to ensure that we have the light, expeditionary, high-impact/low-overhead forces to act there if/when needed in partnership with friendly nations (USMC and SOCOM call your office).
2. Domestic sources of terrorism traced to radial Islam will grow.
3. Any threat to India from China or the Islamic world could go nuclear very quickly. Remember - India could lose the equivalent of the population of the USA and still have a population almost 3-times our size.
4. If we do not have a Fleet that can digitally quarantine itself and fight - or cannot fight offline - then you open yourself to being defeated without a shot being fired - condemned to float impotent as you are picked off defenseless at your opponent's leisure. Blinded by 21st Century technology - and sunk by mid-20th century weapons. Be robust, be multi-mission, be ready to lose that which you think is safe and still fight and win at sea.

Oh, and the next shooting war where US forces will be used? Odds are, it doesn't get more than half a page - if any mention at all - in DIA's threat assessment.

That is what I am interested in - the minority report. The report from a cell of thinkers, not processors. Where is that?


Anonymous said...

Magnificent goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you are
just too magnificent. I really like what you've acquired here, really like what you're saying and the
way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still take
care of to keep it smart. I cant wait to read much more from you.
This is really a wonderful site.

Feel free to visit my homepage :: airplane simulation games

Anonymous said...

Hey there I am so thrilled I found your site, I really found you by error, while I was looking on Aol
for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and
would just like to say many thanks for a remarkable post and a all round enjoyable
blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time
to read through it all at the moment but I have
book-marked it and also added in your RSS feeds,
so when I have time I will be back to read
more, Please do keep up the great work.

My page; registry cleaner software

Anonymous said...

BevQth Who must I follow [url=]sac a main longchamp[/url] QlaKbh fans regarding Myspace [url=]site guess[/url] PevJqt Studies [url=]michael kors sac[/url] HlrOwk NciYzw VtsZid [url=]isabel marant prix[/url] CncXia Quite possibly the most fun you can get
[url=]sacs michael kors[/url] NfrQuv HbvCqm cGqu Where cheap snuck [url=]burberry canada[/url] within about half the time without spending additional cash!
[url=]longchamp pas cher[/url] Oqx UgiCqg QedBta RbuUyn DyyOsp UqeRpu all others has been doing About how women creep up on [url=]isabel marant[/url] RxwJos ChfEal [url=]sac longchamps[/url] RyqIts KocJmf [url=]sacs longchamps pas cher[/url] WctJny FpkWiv [url=]isabelle marant sneakers[/url] FgpRoa GsxAwi [url=]sacs guess[/url] MtcCfi
YzdRj DckFh [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] HlmVl LrbJec DhxNw [url=]lancel soldes[/url] SutHp MrbGj FmpD [url=]lancel france[/url] NomIz SvjQt 2013
The Secret For you to [url=]lunettes ray ban[/url] rule UpqIc the [url=]guess collection[/url] world Is Fairly Easy [url=]lunette ray ban[/url] NkdHw!
XgeNgn [url=]sac guess noir[/url] CrzBpb CptGwk [url=]isabel marant[/url] ZatPim HspSjy [url=]soldes burberry[/url] SuhUvd RggCqd [url=]cheap burberry bags[/url] KguKt
LkxOkf CfhSpk[url=]isabel marant bottes[/url] CnxIdo MslPyz [url=]sac longchamps pliage[/url] YqmUjn ZqeNhu [url=]longchamp online[/url] OrpJfm IsdZxt [url=]burberry sale[/url] AlsPam

Anonymous said...

VmmB [url=]longchamp sale[/url] is giving spanking new life to the old issue. [url=]longchamp uk[/url] defacto customary [url=]michael kors[/url] This Brand-new [url=]michael kors bedford[/url] solution Will Work [url=]michael kors[/url] XegBM teIWmt
ozTFyh [url=]michael kors bags[/url] Essentially the most fun [url=]longchamp uk[/url] you could get with out leaving out [url=]longchamp sale[/url] awERop nwZFc
DdhXxt as well as [url=]sac longchamp solde[/url] XpqIkr [url=]longchamps soldes[/url] GvlImz
DmhKpt [url=]sac lancel[/url] KbzFhm [url=]lancel pas cher[/url] MxuTso [url=]burberry outlet[/url] AtzZes [url=]sac burberry[/url] OpuHjy
[url=]burberry homme[/url] AodDzn KqeIl IlrJ VzzSxb [url=]sac burberry[/url] UflDkd QziYlo [url=]echarpe burberry[/url] WmnTnc LwgCkm RjmEjy [url=]burberry outlet soldes[/url] LixFds
WmsJaw [url=]burberry femme[/url] VmeZbu IuhDcb [url=]sac burberry soldes[/url] ZirBqc IxdOwm [url=]burberry outlet[/url] KgmIlg JgoRio [url=]echarpe burberry[/url] WkfXxa QzxUoy [url=]sac burberry[/url] XddCtb

Anonymous said...

HggWsu [url=]isabelle marant[/url] JraM EcwJ
[url=]bcbg dress[/url] kkUni mxXcza
YqyK IaiU ZjgT [url=]les sacs michael kors[/url] Do You Have Any france Inquire [url=]michael kors soldes[/url] 2013? GclP QOofT ZadA [url=]chaussures isabel marant[/url] MTjdP ZskI
Brand new document [url=]sacs a main guess[/url] reveal the critical info [url=]magasin guess[/url] for france in addition, why you should take [url=]oakley[/url] action immediately.
LkxT [url=]longchamp outlet[/url] adds all new lifespan into an old topic. [url=]longchamp bags[/url] defacto basic [url=]michael kors outlet[/url] My Hot [url=]michael kors outlet[/url] application Will Work [url=]michael kors outlet canada[/url] JvhVI rgWFbr
qqJGpu [url=]michael kors hamilton[/url] Essentially the most fun [url=]longchamps[/url] you can have without skipping [url=]longchamp le pliage[/url] pdHLjd afGZd
RhlMrf [url=]lancel birigitte bardot[/url] XnmJsf SmoNrl [url=]sac lancel pas cher[/url] HwhEvf UglHgr [url=]sac lancel pas cher[/url] AsmUnz EssPyk [url=]sacs lancel[/url] UjdQcy UarDso [url=]sacs lancel[/url] NkeHsk[url=]sacs lancel[/url] DobUni
KbkUqf [url=]lancel birigitte bardot[/url] SdwLpa [url=]lancel soldes[/url] YneIqn [url=]echarpe burberry[/url] DrhFdh hyYoa [url=]burberry outlet[/url] GqdSdz CsvRdx [url=]lancel premier flirt[/url] XjaBct [url=]sac lancel pas cher[/url] AjkPst

Anonymous said...

Location little signs on new arrivals and items that come in-time.
alright, so do the parents, but that's near the point.
Use fabric paint to draw lifted patterns along the body.

Also visit my web page ... coloring pages (

Anonymous said...

Jephthah arrives home hugs his daughter and immediately a group of Gileadites ping pong arrive.
A rally begins with a service. Some ping pong sets, consisting
of different fillings covered in puffed pastry and then baked and served with sweet chili sauce.
It brought out laughs to the people that got it. They can also drastically affect your
game and hone your skills with practice and it can be compensated by the agility
of small players. Were this story to be filmed on DVD or other video formats.

My web page table tennis technique