Friday, January 27, 2012

Fullbore Friday


Yep'r. Today's FbF is a ponder'n one. A "how it should be done" FbF about Fullbore leaders who did it right - and a reminder of what is doing it wrong.

Via Ian Jack;
Chivalry at sea became an essential British ideal, and proof of the superiority of Anglo-Saxons (a category that included North Americans and most northern Europeans) over more panicky peoples from the south and east. The annals of old shipwrecks are filled with implications of their alleged poor behaviour. "I saw a lot of Latin people all along the ship's rails," recalled the Titanic's fifth officer, Harold Lowe. "They were glaring more or less like wild beasts, ready to spring." No Birkenhead drill for him: Lowe was sitting in a lifeboat at the time, being lowered past the still-crowded upper decks, but the awkwardness of his position as an officer leaving his passengers behind to drown seems never to have occurred to him. "Latins" weren't to be trusted in an emergency, and therefore didn't count.

The spectre now haunting Italy is that this label has stuck. "We've gone straight into the Titanic nightmare [and] Italy is once again the laughing stock of foreign newspapers," wrote a blogger, Caterina Soffici, this week. In Il Giornale, the columnist Cristiano Gatti wrote that the rest of the world would be delighted to rediscover "the same old rascally Italians: those unreliable cowards who turn and run in war and flee like rabbits from the ship, even if they are in command". But are either of these statements really true? People who know about ships and seafaring in Britain take pity on Schettino, rather than laugh at him. They puzzle over the course he took that led to the collision with the reef, they wonder how many people were on the bridge with him at the time, and why nobody raised a warning. Perhaps they snigger a little at his account of tripping and falling into a lifeboat ("How odd that his first officer seems to have done the same thing"), but on the whole they understand the torrent of guilt and self-recrimination that must threaten to overwhelm him, first for losing a ship and so many lives and, second, for his subsequent behaviour. None, at least of those I talked to, went as far as Professor Craig Allen of the US Coastguard Academy and accused him of "abject cowardice".

But his transgression is enormous. The rule that a captain must be the last man (or woman) to leave a ship in difficulties is never written down, but everywhere understood. In the words of a former P&O captain: "At sea, you have a great sense of responsibility for the people who are beneath you – it's moral as well as legal. You need to stay as long as anyone else remains."

In this altruistic sense, the mystique of captaincy has survived into its third century. Sentiment, if not always practicality, will ensure it continues. For who can resist the gallantry of David Hart Dyke staying aboard the tilting hull of HMS Coventry, or Noel Coward and what remains of his crew clinging to their life-raft in In Which We Serve, and Coward commanding, as his destroyer finally goes down: "Three cheers for the ship!"
The lessons of 3.5 yrs ago - and still apply today; as do those decades before.

7 comments:

Byron said...

For those SWOs who want to know how the hell could this have happened, go here and click on the .wmv file to get a complete minute by minute (accellerated) recreation of the ships course from just before Costa Concordia hit the rocks (which were visible above the water) till she floated (not under power, just wind and tide) on shoal water):

http://www.qps.nl/display/qastor/2012/01/17/20120117_stranding

Also, unlike the statements made by the captain, this course was nothing like ones taken before to "wave at the island".

bullnav said...

Ernest Evans on JOHNSTON...

Byron said...

Robert Copeland, Lt. Cdr, USS Samuel B. Roberts, DE-413

andrewdb said...

A friend was onboard the Ille de France when it picked up passangers after the Andrea Doria/Stockholm crash.  He said the first boats to arrive all had crewmembers from the AD.  The Captain of the IdF refused to allow them onboard - until they jumped out of the lifeboats into the water.

To this day my friend refuses to sail on Italian liners.

alex w said...

And then there is a different breed of Italian...Fabrizio Quattrocchi.  "Vi faccio vedere come muore un Italiano!" - <span>"I'll show you how an Italian dies!" He was then shot in the back of the neck.</span><sup></sup><span><span><span>[</span>1<span>]</span></span></span><sup></sup><span><span><span>[</span>2<span>]</span></span></span>

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fabrizio_Quattrocchi

Byron said...

You have to look the right picture, but there's a freaking big ass chunk of rock stuck in the gash...about the size of your average subarban two car garage. And the rock was OUT OF THE WATER in CLEAR FREAKING SIGHT!

SCOTTtheBADGER said...

I watched A Night To Remember last night. A much better movie than James Cameron's Titanic.